Women in the Workforce Part 6: Stay Home or Be Paid Less

Women in the Workforce Part 6: Stay Home or Be Paid Less

Posted by Lee Yarborough on 6/22/22 1:42 PM
Lee Yarborough
Find me on:
Posted on: June 22, 2022

Read Part 6 of Women in the Workforce: We Can Do It!, a 14-part series exploring topics related to the history, challenges, and accomplishments of working women in America.

Choosing the Right PEOAfter the war, it was expected that women would move aside and allow the men to return to their previous occupations. The government promoted the view that in peacetime, a mother’s primary duty is to be home with her children. However, not all women felt the same way, and circumstances did not allow women to move right back to their homes. Approximately 75% of women who worked during the war expected to continue their jobs after the war. Interestedly, this included high numbers of married women.

Polls showed that between 47% to 68% of married women wanted to keep working, but employers justified laying off many in favor of veterans returning from the war. The women who did choose to stay in the workforce were usually demoted and paid less. Ninety percent of women who continued to work after the war experienced a decrease in wages. A woman’s average weekly wage dropped from $50 to $37, a decline of almost 26%, compared to the overall decrease of 4% after the war.

➡️➡️READ MORE: 04_Working Women and The Great Depression

In 1947, the Department of Labor unsuccessfully attempted to pass an equal pay amendment. Secretary of Labor Lewis Schwellenbach argued that “There is no sex difference in the food she buys or the rent she pays, there should be none in her pay envelope.” However, cultural norms persisted, and as men returned from the home front, women were expected to stay home or be paid less.

According to the Women’s Bureau studies, of the 75% of women who expected to keep their jobs after the war, 84% felt they had no other alternative and needed to support themselves and their families financially. Eight percent expressed specific reasons such as buying a home or educational expenses which would keep them in the workforce. And only 8% reported that they liked working as the reason to stay part of the labor pool. There was very little difference between the responses of married women and single women. But enlisted men had been guaranteed their jobs back, which meant that women were pushed aside.

AdobeStock_198343034_01The Postwar years were a time of great economic prosperity. The middle class was growing as new jobs and opportunities increased. The GI Bill promoted homeownership, and white, middle-class Americans moved to the suburbs. The 1950s brought an increased focus on the importance of the family.

Traditional gender roles were valued, and it was a period of conformity. After the troubling times of the depression and war, people were in pursuit of the American Dream. Marriage and homeownership rates skyrocketed. Women married young and divorce was rare. The nuclear family was considered the building block to a strong society. The first Baby Boomers were born in 1946, and the idea that women were to be primarily wives and mothers prevailed.

The myth of the ideal woman was prominent in the 1950s. It was a throwback to the Victorian ideas surrounding the virtuous woman. The pants that she wore during the war years were replaced with girdles, full skirts, and unrealistic proportions.

AdobeStock_198343845_01Young women dropped out of college to marry early. The M.R.S. was the most sought-after degree in college. Magazines urged women to pretend to be helpless and dumb to maintain their husband’s love. Women were isolated in the suburbs as the men left each day for their jobs in the city.

The explosive economy created opportunities like no other time in history when a young couple could marry while the husband was still in school, buy a house with no savings, have children right away, and continue to increase their standard of living, all on a single income. Middle-class women everywhere were raising children with the help of Dr. Spock and sharing casserole recipes at the neighborhood get-togethers.

AdobeStock_198345103_01The media reinforced this image of domestic bliss. Television shows such as Leave It to Beaver and Father Knows Best praised the virtues of the perfect family: a hard-working father who provided for his family, a beautiful and adoring mother who kept a clean house and prepared wonderful meals, and mischievous children who learned life lessons in 30 minutes. These shows implied that a woman’s place was only in the home, and being a housewife held the ultimate fulfillment. June Cleaver even wore high heels and pearls while cooking dinner!

Comedian Lucille Ball perpetuated this myth in I Love Lucy. As independent and fun-loving as Lucy seemed, every time she tried to pursue an outside interest or job, she always failed in the most hysterical ways. The episode usually ends with Ricky teaching her a lesson and reminding her that she is best suited as Mrs. Ricky Ricardo. In the very first episode, Ricky states, “I want a wife who’s just a wife.”

➡️➡️READ MORE: 05 The Rise of Female Empowerment

Women’s magazines also promoted traditional gender roles. Articles focused on how to be a better wife, and advertisements targeted women as consumers by playing on her fears of not meeting the ideal domestic standards. African Americans also embraced the notion that a woman’s place is in the home, with a twist based on their traditional place in society. Ebony magazine wrote that Black women should stay in their own kitchens instead of cleaning someone else’s. This was a more powerful message than the magazines geared to white audiences, which promoted submissiveness and helplessness. It was as if women were not interested in anything except housekeeping, children, and the desire to please their husbands. Author Betty Friedan theorized that the change in journalism displayed in the 1950s was a result of women writers leaving their jobs after the war. Male writers replaced them and their ideal of domestic life was pushed.

Women in the Workforce: We Can Do It! 

Whether married or single, with children or not, working part-time, full-time, or even two jobs, as a stay-at-home mom or a community volunteer, American women can do it! Throughout history, American women always have. And I am so proud we do! Over the next few months, I will explore how topics about women in the workforce from the early 1900s until the present. Also, I want to note the changing trends of women in the workforce that this series contemplates will focus on white, middle-class women. Women of color have had very different experiences, and their work lives have been defined by racism, sexism, and financial necessity. I have pointed this out, when possible, but please keep in mind that this series is not a complete picture of all women. 

Please check back to read the next blog in the series, Women in the Workforce: We Can Do It!  Other topics to date include: 01_Women in the Workforce: We Can Do It!, 02_The War Opens the Doors for Working Women, 03_Rise of Jobs, Rise of Inequality,  04_Working Women and The Great Depression and 05 The Rise of Female Empowerment.

Propel HR President Lee Yarborough

Lee Yarborough_PHR_01“My father, Braxton Cutchin, and I founded the company in 1996. After being in the PEO and HR world for 25 years, I have experienced firsthand the value we can provide to both the clients and the employees. It is truly a win for all parties. I’m proud to have helped establish Propel HR as an industry forerunner in the Southeast. There is nothing I love more than receiving phone calls from clients who seek my advice as a trusted advisor. This is a business where I feel that I can help others, and that is important to my own value.”

 -- Lee Yarborough, President, Propel HR

Active in many professional and community organizations, Lee recently served as Chair of the Board of Directors of the National Association of Professional Employer Organizations (NAPEO). As NAPEO Chair, Lee focused on diversity and initiatives to deepen member relations. Under her leadership, she formed Women in NAPEO (WIN), a networking group designed to engage, empower, and encourage women working in the PEO industry. On the local level, Lee also served as the Chair of NAPEO’s Carolinas Leadership Council for more than a decade. In 2015, she was named a Fellow of the eleventh class of the Liberty Fellowship Program and a member of the Aspen Global Leadership Network.

An advocate for public education, Lee has served on the executive board as Chair of Public Education Partners and is the founder and director of Read Up Greenville, a young adult and middle grades book festival in downtown Greenville, SC.

When she breaks from board meetings, client visits, and networking, most likely, you will find Lee reading, camping, or spending time with her family. She also enjoys volunteering at her church and staying involved with her children's schools.

Choosing the Right PEOAbout Propel HR. Propel HR is an IRS-certified PEO that has been a leading provider of human resources and payroll solutions for 25 years. Propel partners with small to midsized businesses to manage payroll, employee benefits, compliance and risks, and other HR functions in a way that maximizes efficiency and reduces costs. Visit our new website, www.propelhr.com.

Topics: Featured, Women

Subscribe to our Blog for Fresh Weekly Content

7 Heartfelt Ways to Show Employees You Care

Employees thrive in environments where they feel valued and supported, and while a ... Read More

Embracing the Hybrid Work Model

As remote work gains popularity, more businesses are adopting hybrid work models. Here's ... Read More

Survey Savvy

Here are some tips on how to get the best results from surveys.  Read More


HR Division of Propel HR

The HR Division is made up of a team of professionals with a vast level of experience and HR expertise, assisting organizations of all sizes and within a wide variety of industries. They readily partner with clients to address strategic and compliance challenges surrounding the employment life-cycle and the ever-changing laws that regulate it. Inquire below about how they can help you!